Blog

No Silhouette No Painting- How artists sabotage the silhouette.


In my last blog post I talked about the concept of how a simple value pattern or silhouette underlies great paintings.  It is one thing to talk about simplifying a painting it is another thing to put it into practice.  Finding the silhouette and maintaining it throughout the painting process is the most difficult concept for artists to grasp.  It is something I struggle with  and part of that struggle is overcoming misconceptions about what makes a painting work.  Here are some common beliefs that steer artists away from creating a simple value pattern.

I love detail- you can be as detailed as you want as long as the values stay within the range of the silhouette.  Artists run into trouble when they paint “things” without regard to the surrounding values and colors.

If I add more it will be better- Paintings are visual converstions between the artist and the viewer, keep the story simple and uncluttered for major impact.  If you want to know if your painting has too much information, put it on an easel then step about 10 feet away.  Use your hand to cover up parts of the painting.  If the painting looks better when you block a part of it off then there is too much going on in that section.  Here is a tool that can help you simplify without destroying all your hard work.  To soften a pastel painting take a paper towel and fold it.  Use the folded edge and very lightly drag it across the surface.  This will soften the pastel without disturbing the drawing.  With an oil painting a palette knife scraped across the canvas will do wonders.

I’ll keep working on the (nose, tree, eye, cup handle) until I get it right. – leave it alone and paint around it.  Every inch of your paper or canvas is important and each stroke will work only in comparison with what it is placed against.  An eye will look like an eye if you paint the cheekbone, side plane of the nose and brow bone as their correct form and value. 

I love bright color- color without regards to value is useless.  The correct color is always the correct value; the correct value is not always the correct color.  Too much bright color is jarring you need some neutral tones to play the strong colors against.  Also pay attention to the light source.  Mud is created when artists paint light that is inconsistent with the light source.

In my next blog posts I give you some tools to overcome these problems.

   

This is a work in progress from a lesson I taught in my studio recently.  Using Adobe Photoshop we cropped in the photograph to find a composition we liked then put the photograph into grayscale then reduced it to 2 values in posterize.  The goal of the lesson was to keep the silhoutte simple while suggesting detail.

Comments

14 Responses to No Silhouette No Painting- How artists sabotage the silhouette.

very helpful thank you !

Valuable information, thank you for sharing!

Thank you, Shelly and Paula, I'm glad you liked the blog!

I should have read this blog before my painting session today. I had a very busy, highly detailed painting going on till I threw it on the floor, sprayed the surface wit water and painted wet into wet (acrylics. Then I mopped, I added paint, I drew into it and sprayed it again in strategic places. I set it out to dry on the lawn in the sun. The brilliant color that was there before had magically been toned down. The multitude of lines that were there, were softened and a whole lot of blending happened. I came away happier. Letting loose freed it up--and made for a good time, if not a good painting? It's nice to know an artist of your calibre shares these problems and is willing to talk about them.

This is incredibly "value"-able. (Sorry.) I do struggle with value and I especially love the idea of referencing a black and white of the resource photo. Will try it. Great tips ...thank you!

Thank you, Linda and Michelle! I'm glad you found the post "value"-able (love it!). I found that when a painting isn't working wiping it down is the best thing I can do. It's surprising how often it fixes the problem. If I keep working on something that is wrong I rarely make it right. Usually whatever my attempts at fixing things will just call attention to the fact that I was in trouble in the first place. John Singer Sargent was notorious for scraping his paintings when he was not happy with them. Guess we are in good company!

Thank you for sharing. I look forward to reading this blog!

Very simple advice, but extremely helpful. Thank you!! I see this happen all the time in watercolor paintings. Many artists forsake value for color. I try to work on the painting as a whole. But I love the idea of using a b/w version of a photo as a guide. I will surely find it helpful in the future.

Thank you, Beth and Kathleen!

Terrific post, Vianna!

Thank you, Lee! That was a great article on you and your beautiful work in the latest Pastel Journal, congratulations!

Thank you, Vianna. I was very happy with the article and really appreciate your kind comment.

Hi Vianna,
I miss you classes!!!!!! I have read this blog at least 10 times and try to remember "SIMPLE" when I am painting. I love your use of color and that is what makes simple work. I keep working at it. Carol

Hi Carol,
I miss classes too!!! I have been traveling a lot and the workshops have been a great way to keep up my teaching mojo but I REALLY loved the weekly classes and miss you guys terribly.

Simplicity is the hardest concept to trust in art. We always think adding more will make a better painting. The problem occurs if the artist does not identify a visual narrative utilizing elements of shape,value,edge,and color. Painting "stuff" confuses the viewer by breaking the narrative into parts that are not cohesive.

Hey, thanks for letting me go into teacher-speak, that was fun!


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post